Common Wisdom Deserves A Closer Look
Body

Does Shaving Make Hair Grow Back Thicker? A Researcher Tested It in 1928

A boy shaves the faint mustache above his lip. A few days later, the short hairs feel surprisingly sharp. Someone warned him that every shave would make his facial hair stronger, and now he has what looks like proof. Does shaving make hair grow back thicker? The belief has survived for generations, partly because the evidence seems so obvious in the bathroom mirror.

Black-and-white close-up of an older man shaving his gray beard with a disposable razor, illustrating whether shaving makes hair grow back thicker.

No. Shaving does not change a hair’s diameter, color, or growth rate. It cuts the visible shaft and leaves a blunt end that feels rough as it emerges. Mayo Clinic confirms that the effect is only apparent. Does shaving make hair thicker? The answer is equally clear, and anatomist Mildred Trotter began testing the old belief nearly a century ago.

In this article

Four Men, One Patch of Cheek, and a 1928 Experiment

Man shaving his beard with a blue disposable razor and shaving foam, showing a close-up of facial hair removal.
The story of shaving research began with a small experiment in St. Louis.

In February 1928, Trotter, at Washington University in St. Louis, published Hair Growth and Shaving in The Anatomical Record. She examined beard hair on the left cheeks of four men. Her experiment addressed a familiar question: does shaving make hair grow back thicker, or at least faster?

Trotter tried to keep the conditions consistent. The men used the same brand of shaving soap and water at the same temperature for successive shaves. Razor conditions were kept as uniform as possible. She measured the collected hairs and calculated average growth over intervals since the previous shave.

The care devoted to soap and razors deserves attention. Someone could easily have declared the myth true after feeling a rough chin. Trotter made measurements instead. Does shaving make hair grow back thicker after repeated shaves? Her results gave no evidence that the process stimulated beard growth.

Four participants were hardly a representative sample, and Trotter mainly addressed growth rate rather than every characteristic of body hair. Does shaving make hair thicker in terms of actual hair diameter? That required a different measurement, one researchers would make decades later.

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by pixelcourt (@pixel.court.en)

A Razor Can’t Reach the Follicle

Hair grows in follicles beneath the skin’s surface. A razor trims the dead, keratin-filled shaft above that surface. It does not alter the cells responsible for producing the hair. Cleveland Clinic’s explanation helps establish why the biology matters. Does shaving make hair grow back thicker by changing the follicle? An ordinary shave never reaches the structures responsible for hair production.

An uncut hair can have a fine, tapered end. Cut across its wider shaft, and the exposed end feels stiff. Rough stubble reflects the shape of that tip. Does shaving make hair thicker at the exposed end? It creates a blunt edge without increasing the diameter produced by the follicle.

A similar misconception surrounds what happens to hair and nails after death. Our article on whether hair and nails grow after death explains why they can appear to keep growing.

The 1970 Test Used an Unshaved Leg as a Control

Man shaving hair from his leg with a blue disposable razor in a bathtub, illustrating a leg-hair growth experiment.
Instead of relying on appearances, researchers measured the hair itself.

In 1970, Yelva Lynfield and Peter Macwilliams revisited the claim in the Journal of Investigative Dermatology. Their leg-hair experiment involved five healthy young men who shaved one leg weekly for several months and left the other untouched. The researchers could compare two areas on the same person, an important advantage when testing does shaving make hair grow back thicker.

They examined hair collected within a measured 10-by-10-centimeter area, assessing its weight, the width of individual hairs, and the rate of growth. No statistically significant differences could be attributed to shaving. Does shaving make hair thicker? The width measurement addressed that claim directly.

The comparison is more useful than another photograph of stubble. A photograph can show how short hair looks, but the researchers measured physical characteristics. Does shaving make hair grow back thicker after months of weekly shaving? The results provided no evidence of such an effect.

The sample was small and limited to men’s leg hair. Still, the experiment offered an independent comparison more than four decades after Trotter’s work.

The findings add to a question that has persisted for generations. In the short video below, Man Explains Everything revisits the common belief about shaving and hair growth.

Why Fresh Stubble Keeps the Myth Alive

Appearance adds another source of confusion. A freshly cut shaft has not had the same exposure to sunlight as an older tip. A 2007 BMJ review noted that new hair may appear darker because sunlight and chemical exposures have not yet lightened it. Does shaving make hair grow back thicker simply because the new growth looks darker? Color and diameter are separate characteristics.

Puberty makes the story even more convincing. Cleveland Clinic explains that rising androgen levels can turn fine vellus hairs into thicker, darker terminal hairs. A teenager may start shaving just as his beard naturally becomes denser.

Does shaving make hair thicker during puberty? Hormonal development provides the explanation for that natural change. The beard would have developed even without a razor. The sequence is easy to misinterpret. Someone starts shaving, notices thicker facial hair months later, and remembers the warning received before the first shave. The biological changes occurring during adolescence rarely receive the same attention.

What Shaving Can Change and What It Can’t

Shaving can irritate skin or cause razor bumps. The American Academy of Dermatology recommends softening hair with water and using shaving cream. Shaving in the direction of hair growth can help reduce irritation.

Does shaving make hair grow back thicker after years of daily use? Neither experiment supports that claim, and the known biology of hair follicles gives no reason to expect such a result. Regular shaving affects the visible shaft and can affect the skin around it.

Does shaving make hair thicker when irritation makes new stubble more noticeable? Skin irritation and hair diameter are different issues. A sudden, unexplained increase in facial or body hair deserves medical attention because medications or hormonal conditions may be involved.

Trotter’s four participants remain a memorable part of the research. Nearly a century ago, she approached an everyday belief with careful measurements, right down to the shaving soap. Her experiment gave researchers an early way to examine does shaving make hair grow back thicker without relying on appearances.

Those measurements deserve more trust than a prickly chin.

Miscellana

Written by

Miscellana

The Miscellana editorial team examines familiar claims about food, the body, the home, and nature. We look at scientific research, official guidance, and historical sources to establish what the evidence supports. Our articles explain how everyday beliefs became popular and why some deserve a second look. We approach old advice with curiosity and respect, without making readers feel foolish for believing it.